Match

Mark Clattenburg not convinced that Celtic should have had a penalty given against them vs Aberdeen

Add as preferred source on Google

Mark Clattenburg has told 67 Hail Hail that he thinks that Nick Walsh’s decision to award Aberdeen a penalty against Celtic was soft.

Walsh pointed to the spot after Liam Scales was accused of clipping the foot of Toyosi Olusanya inside the box, which enabled Kevin Nisbet to equalise at Pittodrie.

Celtic went on to win 2-1 and move up to second in the table, but judging by Clattenburg’s comments, they may consider themselves unfortunate to not come away with a clean sheet.

Who is your Celtic man of the match from that HUGE win against Aberdeen?

Why Mark Clattenburg thinks Aberdeen’s penalty was soft

The former FIFA referee was watching events unfold at Pittodrie and believes that if Walsh had never pointed to the spot, VAR would have never overturned the decision, which therefore made it somewhat harsh for the Hoops.

He told 67 Hail Hail: “Toyosi Olusanya is backing into Liam Scales and the Celtic defender swings a boot and he makes contact with the Dons striker.

“The contact is a soft one and once the referee awards the penalty then VAR will not interfere.

“That said, I am sure if the referee does not give this penalty, the VAR would also not interfere. The defender certainly took a risk in trying to play the ball and I think the attacker is clever in moving his leg across to create the contact.”

Do you agree with Mark Clattenburg’s view on Aberdeen’s penalty?

Liam Scales of Celtic is seen during the UEFA Europa League 2025/26 League Phase MD8 match between Celtic FC and FC Utrecht
Credit: Ian MacNicol/Getty Images

Should Celtic have been awarded a penalty against Aberdeen?

The hosts were handed a spot-kick but were Celtic unfortunate to not get one of their own?

A cross into the Aberdeen box from Sebastian Tounekti hit the hand of Jack Milne, but replays showed that his arm was tucked in close to his chest.

Chris Sutton, Kris Boyd and Johnny Hayes all agreed in the Sky Sports studio that the right call was made as Milne’s hand was in a natural position with nowhere to move his arm.