VAR remains one of the most divisive topics for Celtic and Scottish football, with every contentious decision reigniting debate over whether the system is fit for purpose.
Yet former SFA referee Des Roache has identified the issue many continue to overlook.
Rather than blaming the technology, Roache believes attention should be directed towards the officials operating it. His assessment of an incident in Celtic’s win over Hearts highlights why that distinction matters.
- READ MORE: Gary Lineker and Terry Butcher invent bizarre new theory over Celtic’s Motherwell penalty
Craig Gordon feels ‘injustice’ over Celtic’s title win?
What is he talking about? Let us know in the comments 👇
Des Roache says Celtic goal against Hearts proves VAR works
Speaking about VAR and its problems in Scottish football, the former SFA referee highlighted Daizen Maeda’s goal against Hearts at Celtic Park as a reason why the technology works.
Roache told The Sunday Post, “I don’t think that VAR is the problem, the issue is the people who are operating it, and how they’re being coached and educated to use it.
“We’ve seen in Celtic’s last league game against Hearts with the offside decision, assistant Dave Roome got it wrong, but match official Don Robertson called it right. Technology works. It’s how you’re being coached and applied to use it.”
It is a point that deserves serious consideration. VAR is designed to assist officials, not replace them. The system can only be as effective as the people making decisions before and during the review process.
Celtic goal proves Scottish football keeps targeting the wrong problem
The current VAR protocol places responsibility on officials to make and review key decisions, with the referee retaining ultimate authority. That means controversy often stems from judgement rather than technology.
Roache’s comments are significant because they come from someone who understands the demands placed on referees.
His argument is not that VAR is flawless. Instead, he is questioning whether officials are receiving the coaching, education and support required to use it consistently.
Celtic supporters are entitled to scrutinise decisions that affect their club. However, Roache’s assessment suggests Scottish football may be focusing on the wrong target.
If the people operating the system are making mistakes, then improving standards and accountability should take priority over attacking the technology itself.
Receive a digest of our best Celtic content each week direct to your mailbox
