The conspiracy theory around Celtic receiving favourable treatment from referees falls apart the second people actually look at the numbers.
Celtic’s title win has fans of Rangers and Hearts screaming about the achievement being helped by poor refereeing decisions.
The current Scottish Premiership statistics do not support the outrage, they completely undermine it.
Supporters across Scotland constantly claim Celtic benefit from soft decisions while clubs like Hearts and Rangers are treated differently. The data says otherwise and makes those claims look absolutely ridiculous.
Just how badly has the SFA’s VAR audio from the Premiership finale reflected on Hearts…
Celtic’s yellow card numbers completely undermine the narrative
The official SPFL statistics show Celtic have collected 78 yellow cards this season.
Rangers have fewer with 73 while Hearts sit even lower on 69. Those numbers immediately expose the nonsense surrounding claims that Celtic are somehow protected by referees.
If officials were consistently favouring Celtic, the disciplinary totals would reflect it. Instead, Celtic are one of the most-booked teams in the division and have received more yellow cards than both clubs whose supporters complain the loudest.
Celtic’s red card figures raise bigger questions about Rangers
Celtic have received two red cards in league action this season. Hearts have five while Rangers have just one.
That alone makes the outrage directed at Celtic look ridiculous. Rival supporters constantly frame Celtic as the beneficiaries of refereeing decisions, yet Rangers have received fewer yellow cards and fewer red cards than Celtic.
If anyone wanted to force a narrative from the disciplinary statistics, the numbers would arguably support questions about leniency towards Rangers far more than Celtic.
The reality is far less dramatic. Card totals are influenced by playing style, defending, game management and individual mistakes. What the statistics definitely do not show is a league-wide effort to protect Celtic from punishment.
Celtic’s penalty numbers destroy Rangers Hearts narrative
The biggest myth of all surrounds penalties.
The Scottish Premiership penalties table shows Celtic have eight penalties and Rangers had seven awarded this season. Hearts are only three behind on five.
In fact, Hearts only had ONE penalty conceded all season and that came in the Celtic Park title decider. Considering the VAR day and age, that is quite a statistic in itself, especially when Celtic conceded six.
That completely destroys the idea that officials are artificially inflating Celtic’s results through penalty decisions.
The more obvious explanation is also the correct one. Celtic dominate possession, spend more time attacking and enter opposition penalty areas more frequently than most teams in Scotland. Attacking sides win penalties. That is football, not corruption.
The statistics are not complicated and they are not ambiguous. Celtic are not receiving extraordinary protection from referees. The numbers simply do not support the hysteria.
Receive a digest of our best Celtic content each week direct to your mailbox
