Acun Ilıcalı has just shown how weak Celtic’s favourite excuse has become. The Hull City owner spoke about recruitment without revealing bids, fees or private talks.
He challenged claims that players had rejected Hull, said work had been going on for two months and told supporters a squad was being built. Celtic normally leave those stories unanswered until frustration has already taken hold.
Michael Nicholson does not need to name targets or discuss offers. Supporters have asked what Celtic’s plan is, but the board keep defending information nobody asked them to reveal.
😬 Is Calvin Stengs still worth a punt on a free transfer for Celtic?
His recent injury record is damning…
Hull City have exposed Celtic’s confidentiality excuse
Ilıcalı’s message did not explain every part of Hull’s transfer window. It challenged the media narrative and confirmed that the club had been working on deals.
Celtic said last September that successful transfers had to be negotiated privately and kept confidential until agreements were completed. Fine, but that does not answer why the club says so little about its recruitment plans.
Celtic do not need to deny every name linked with the club. They can still challenge claims that players keep rejecting them if they believe those claims are false.
Hull have kept the details of their negotiations private. Ilıcalı has told supporters that work is being done and made clear that the rejection stories have bothered him.
Celtic supporters never asked Michael Nicholson for transfer secrets
Official minutes from Celtic’s meeting with supporter groups last October recorded exactly what representatives wanted. They asked to understand the club’s strategy, not details about individual or reported transfers.
Nicholson accepted that supporters wanted better communication and said the matter would be taken forward. They replied that promises to look at concerns and return with answers had become the “same old story”.
Nine months later, the Celtic Supporters Association again criticised the lack of communication from the club. The board has already been told exactly what supporters are asking for.
Celtic’s silence has not stopped alleged rejections and failed moves becoming the story of the window. Ilıcalı has shown that transfer talks can stay private while the people running the club still speak.
Receive a digest of our best Celtic content each week direct to your mailbox
