Marcelo Saracchi’s agent has now claimed Celtic never offered the Uruguayan a permanent deal despite his impressive loan spell in Glasgow.
Celtic fans would have been hopeful a deal could have been struck considering Boca Juniors are looking to offload Saracchi this summer.
For many supporters, that claim will be the most frustrating part of the entire situation because Saracchi did more than enough to suggest he could contribute again next season.
Only one of Kieran Tierney and Marcelo Saracchi can start against Kilmarnock
Who are you picking?
Marcelo Saracchi proved his value during his Celtic loan
That revelation feels surprising considering how dependable Saracchi looked whenever Celtic called upon him this season.
He was never going to displace Kieran Tierney long term, but Celtic still appeared to have a reliable and experienced squad option sitting right in front of them.
The left-back made 27 appearances across all competitions and brought energy, aggression and consistency whenever he featured.
His numbers were solid, his attitude never became an issue and he adapted quickly to the demands of Scottish football. Even in a rotational role behind Tierney, Saracchi looked comfortable in the system and gave Celtic dependable cover during a long campaign.
That matters. Celtic need depth capable of stepping in immediately without weakening the side, especially with domestic and European demands increasing every season.
Saracchi already understood the environment, the expectations and the intensity required to play for the club.
Saracchi agent update changes the Celtic conversation
There had been reports suggesting Celtic explored talks with Boca Juniors over a permanent move, but the latest comments from Saracchi’s representative paint a very different picture.
If Celtic genuinely never followed through with an offer, it raises questions about what more the defender realistically needed to do.
Supporters quickly warmed to him because he looked committed every time he played. He never carried himself like a short-term stopgap and his performances backed that up.
Saracchi may not have been viewed internally as a long-term starter, but allowing a proven and trusted option to walk away still feels like a strange decision after the season he produced.
Receive a digest of our best Celtic content each week direct to your mailbox
